May 的心里话 --- 打官司的原因和过程可能不令人愉快，但好结果可以让人很开心！

我选择新西兰

这几天，在不到一周的时间内，我收到了两份法庭的判决书。

一份判决书来自ERA， 我代理的一位Kiwi客户的劳资纠纷案胜诉。


May的心里话：做一份自己喜欢且胜任的工作真好。


一份判决书来自High Court, 我作为被告的诽谤案终于结案了， 对方败诉。


May的心里话：做被告的感觉和打官司的过程不会令当事人愉快，但胜诉的心情弥补了一切。将近三年半的法律程序，我学到很多。


待续。

孜然炒肉

大名鼎鼎的May，鼠版的最爱

DisconnectHack

诽谤的案件不是本来就很难胜诉的嘛？

joy___123

占座听故事

微苦蓝山

哈哈，5F的案子吧

masterq

http://bbs.skykiwi.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=2069551

mimisa

祝贺。。。。

Olga

May 是谁？  

Jacky在奋斗

哈哈哈哈哈

我选择新西兰

Olga 发表于 2016-12-21 17:14
May 是谁？

我是天维网的一名网友，网名“我选择新西兰”。 我原来的网名是“选择新西兰”。

我选择新西兰

DisconnectHack 发表于 2016-12-21 16:17
诽谤的案件不是本来就很难胜诉的嘛？

就我的案子来说，我从来没有怀疑过自己的判断，不管是用common sense, 还是用legal principle,

我从始至终都认为自己的案子不会输。

楼主

我懒,谁可以给个链接?最好是可以简单地概括一下,还有ratio decidendi什么的.

我选择新西兰

楼主 发表于 2016-12-21 17:50
我懒,谁可以给个链接?最好是可以简单地概括一下,还有ratio decidendi什么的.

判决书摘录：

Introduction
[1] This is an action for defamation taken by Yi Wu, also known as Easter Wu, a businessman and frequent contributor to a forum on an internet website, http://www.skykiwi.com, (Skykiwi), against May Moncur, another contributor to the same forum, who he claims defamed him in comments she made on the forum in response to a post under the username “Wu Fu”.

[2] Ms Moncur was also instrumental in bringing Wu Fu’s post to the attention of the Truth newspaper, which published an article about the post that included comments from Bob Kerridge of the Auckland Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals.

[3] Mr Wu’s defamation claim originally named a reporter for the Truth newspaper as the second defendant, a director of the Truth newspaper company (the company) as the third defendant, the company itself as the fourth defendant and Mr Kerridge as the fifth defendant.

[4] The second defendant was unable to be served with the proceedings. It is believed that he is in Australia. Mr Wu settled with the third and fifth defendants. The fourth defendant was liquidated and has now been struck off the Companies Register altogether. Mr Wu recognises that no real remedy is available against the company, but nonetheless seeks a declaration against it in vindication of his reputation.

[5] Ms Moncur is, in effect, the sole remaining defendant. Mr Wu seeks $250,000 general damages and $7,500 punitive damages against her. He also seeks a permanent injunction to restrain her from continuing with her defamatory comments.

Conclusion

[56] The defamation claim by Mr Wu against Ms Moncur is dismissed on the basis that her original post on 30 March 2013 was not defamatory. Ms Moncur has also established the defence of honest opinion to my satisfaction both in respect of her original post on 30 March 2013 and the post of the Truth article on 18 April 2013.

[57] Ms Moncur was not represented in the High Court hearing so I am unaware of her entitlement to costs. If costs remain an issue, memoranda by both parties should be filed by 31 January 2017.

我选择新西兰

hkw516 发表于 2016-12-21 16:32
案件的输赢重要么？

重要的难道不是利益？

在我看来，过程和结果都重要。

不是很理解你的发言，请赐教。

qlc178901

顶！！！！！！！清者不但要自清，还得客观证明清白才更心安

Olga

我选择新西兰 发表于 2016-12-21 17:43
我是天维网的一名网友，网名“我选择新西兰”。 我原来的网名是“选择新西兰”。  ...

谢谢回答。

qlc178901

希望may少受到这种旷日持久的官司纠缠而气馁妥协，再接再厉。。。。。加油！

我选择新西兰

qlc178901 发表于 2016-12-21 18:05
希望may少受到这种旷日持久的官司纠缠而气馁妥协，再接再厉。。。。。加油！ ...

一天一个谢，给楼上。

kei

我觉得原告的目的已经达到了

我选择新西兰

kei 发表于 2016-12-21 18:17
我觉得原告的目的已经达到了

过去的两年里，我自己代理自己的案子，学习到许多东西。我也达到了自己根本没有预想到得目的，喜悦兴奋之余，感到收获匪浅。

DisconnectHack

我选择新西兰 发表于 2016-12-21 16:50
就我的案子来说，我从来没有怀疑过自己的判断，不管是用common sense, 还是用legal principle,

我从始 ...

武夫咋不上论坛了，跟这案子没关系吧

masterq

DisconnectHack 发表于 2016-12-21 19:00
武夫咋不上论坛了，跟这案子没关系吧

他說過要入股收購屎蓋,二年半過去了,沒臉上來吧~~

DisconnectHack

masterq 发表于 2016-12-21 18:04
他說過要入股收購屎蓋,二年半過去了,沒臉上來吧~~

晕屎

我选择新西兰

在新西兰高院打官司，一扯就可以是好几年，好在我的职业让我对走法律程序没有情绪上的障碍，也不太着急，加上是自己处理案子，每个环节都清楚。整个过程下来，感觉自己付出了，更得到了。

雨初霁

三年半。。。。。

这官司打的真煎熬。。。。不过楼主能过个很开心的圣诞。

ilikeauckland

恭喜恭喜， 圣诞节快乐

ryanlu

wa bujiandana !

柒夜之月

有没有懒人包 吃瓜群众看不懂啊 大神解释下呗

Clark1129

少整点配菜吧，我敢说没有人对第一个什么劳资纠纷有兴趣