Comlaw前輩請進.. 關於Case問題

Vy2

我想問.. 回答問題是不是寫Case越多越高分阿???
看了自己的test script感覺好像這樣..
所以說.. 想拿A因該多看看case??

不一样

我正在学- -

test之前看了不少case

说实话

感觉用处不是灰常大

CEOjennifer

比起看更多的case,你更需要理解每个case里面的principles/rules/ratios, in order to apply them ACCURATELY & THOROUGHLY  to the facts in the exam questions; 考试题目一般都是根据某个case's fact改编的，到时候就看你能否pick out the best case for application,
and remember to make an alternative argument if ur aiming for A

CEOjennifer

我正在学- -

test之前看了不少case

说实话

感觉用处不是灰常大
不一样 发表于 2009-10-18 19:28

common law's authority is all about cases, 如果不能理解每个案例的话，的确看了没什么用。。。好好努力啊

KennyYu

I hate citing cases coz they are of no use, let alone illustrating the application of principles.

I'd have thought the only use of cases is there for you to differentiate them from the scenario at hand in a way that favors your case and thus stand apart from other students' answers.

kevin21334

如果一道題有10分的話  你寫一個case就可以拿1/2分 寫多幾個也是一樣的

~Kurosagi~

不是case 越多越高分
而是你case 用的對 就好了

charlie2e

每个topic 记住一2个 老师重点说的 101的话 contract就是那个carbolic什么的
并不是越多case越好
重点是找一个case跟exam题类似的。。
exam题都是从书上的case改编的

Vy2

hmm ok..
what i wrote in my answer was something like.. a similar cases was decided like this.. so i wrote that case in my answer to support my argument
in 101.. i think even if i only had 1 case the marker still gave me lots marks for putting in the right sections,
but for 301.. it seems that they are looking for more cases? maybe because theres a lot of case laws???

Vy2

比起看更多的case,你更需要理解每个case里面的principles/rules/ratios, in order to apply them ACCURATELY & THOROUGHLY  to the facts in the exam questions; 考试题目一般都是根据某个case's fact改编的，到时候 ...
CEOjennifer 发表于 2009-10-18 20:43

alternative argument... is it like.. you should argue both ways? eg: the case can be decided like this and decided in another way?

CEOjennifer

alternative argument... is it like.. you should argue both ways? eg: the case can be decided like this and decided in another way?
Vy2 发表于 2009-10-20 00:16

exactly, but u still have to make a conclusion in the end like...on the balance of probabilities...choose the most likely outcome you(or the court) may be likely to reach and state why

joanaliang

depends on what you write